Ecojay SmartZone vs. Honeywell TrueZone: Which Zone Controller Is Better?

When it comes to residential HVAC zoning, the control panel is the brain of the system. It determines how effectively your home’s heating and cooling are distributed across different zones. Two of the most talked‑about options on the market are the Ecojay SmartZone series and the Honeywell TrueZone series. But which one is the better choice for homeowners and contractors in 2025?

Let’s break down both options, their pros and cons, and see which zone controller comes out on top.

Why Choosing the Right Zone Panel Matters

A zone control panel manages thermostats, dampers, and HVAC equipment so each zone in a home can be independently heated or cooled. The right panel makes installation simple, reduces troubleshooting headaches, and ensures maximum comfort and energy savings. The wrong choice can mean callbacks, frustration, and unhappy homeowners.

Ecojay SmartZone Overview

The Ecojay SmartZone 3.0 series (including the SmartZone‑4X and SmartZone‑3X) is a newer generation of zone panels designed with contractors and DIY‑savvy homeowners in mind.

Features and Benefits

• Universal compatibility with almost any 24VAC thermostat and damper system

• Supports conventional, heat pump, dual‑fuel, and multi‑stage systems

• Built‑in supply air sensor for equipment staging (up to 3H/2C)

• LED indicators for easy wiring and troubleshooting

• Simple installation and clear labeling

• Strong 5‑year warranty and U.S.‑based support

Pros

• Works with virtually any system configuration

• Faster installs thanks to intuitive wiring

• Reliable long‑term performance

• Excellent customer support and documentation

• Expandable (up to 20 zones) for future-proof install

Cons

• Ecojay does not sell or offer thermostats (This could be seen as a PRO because it means you are free to choose any thermostat you want)

Honeywell TrueZone Overview

The Honeywell TrueZone series (HZ322, HZ432, HZ311, etc.) has been around for years and is one of the most common zoning platforms found in homes today.

Features and Benefits

• Designed for 2‑, 3‑, and 4‑zone setups

• Familiar brand with widespread availability

• Works with most Honeywell thermostats

Pros

• Well‑known name in the HVAC industry

• Often used by contractors familiar with Honeywell systems

• Good availability through wholesalers

Cons

• Reported reliability issues, with frequent replacements needed after only a few years

• Must use Honeywell thermostats

• More complicated wiring and setup compared to SmartZone

• Limited staging and fresh‑air integration features

• Support is limited to “authorized dealers”

Which One Should You Choose?

If you want ease of installation, maximum compatibility, and long‑term reliability, the Ecojay SmartZone series is the clear winner. The SmartZone‑4X is ideal for larger homes (4 zones - Up to 20 with expandability), while the SmartZone‑3X is the best value for mid‑sized setups.

Honeywell TrueZone panels still have their place, especially for contractors who work mainly with Honeywell thermostats. However, reliability concerns and fewer advanced features make them less attractive for new installs in 2025.

Where to Buy Zone Control Panels

At ZoningSupply.com, you’ll find the full range of Ecojay SmartZone control boards, dampers, and accessories, along with replacement parts for Honeywell and Arzel systems. Whether you’re upgrading an existing setup or starting fresh, we have the products and support to make your project a success.

✅ Final Verdict

• Best Overall: Ecojay SmartZone‑4X (ZS4X‑3.0)

• Best Value: Ecojay SmartZone‑3X (ZS3X‑3.0)

• Still Available: Honeywell TrueZone (HZ432, HZ322) for legacy installs

Sale

SmartZone-4X 3.0

Sale Price: $269.99 Original Price: $299.00

SmartZone-3X 3.0

$199.99

When it comes to performance, reliability, and support, Ecojay SmartZone is the smarter choice for HVAC zoning in 2025.

How to Operate an HVAC Zoning System Efficiently

Managing your home's HVAC system efficiently ensures comfort, energy savings, and longevity for your equipment. With a 4-zone SmartZone control system, Vine connected Wi-Fi thermostats, and EcoJay’s Outdoor Temperature Controller with free-cooling features (economizer), you have the tools to achieve optimal performance. Here are some tips to get the most out of your setup:

1. Set Smart Thermostat Schedules

Using the scheduling feature on your Vine Wi-Fi thermostats is one of the easiest ways to save energy:

• Create zone-specific schedules based on occupancy. For instance, prioritize heating or cooling in bedrooms during the night and in common areas during the day.

• Set back temperatures when zones are unoccupied. For example, raise the cooling setpoint by 4–6°F or lower the heating setpoint by 8–10°F.

2. Take Advantage of the Free-Cooling Feature

The free-cooling feature, also known as an economizer, can reduce energy usage by leveraging outdoor air for cooling when the conditions are favorable. EcoJay’s Outdoor Temperature Controller makes this easy:

• Understand the conditions for free-cooling: Free-cooling is effective when outdoor air is cooler than your indoor setpoint and has low humidity.

• Configure your economizer settings:

  • Set the temperature threshold on the Outdoor Temperature Controller to activate free-cooling (e.g., when outdoor temperatures are below 60°F).

  • Adjust the dampers to let in fresh, cool outdoor air while minimizing mechanical cooling.

• Use during transitional seasons: Spring and fall are ideal for economizer use, as outdoor temperatures are often moderate.

• Monitor system operation: Ensure the economizer dampers and controller are functioning correctly to avoid overcooling or bringing in excessive humidity.

3. Balance Zones Appropriately

• Ensure proper damper operation: Verify that the dampers for each zone respond correctly to thermostat commands. Stuck or malfunctioning dampers can lead to inefficiency and discomfort.

• Avoid extreme setpoints: Large temperature differences between zones can strain your HVAC system. Keep setpoints within 5°F to 10°F of each other for smoother operation.

• Minimize unused zones: If a zone is rarely used, set its thermostat to a minimal setting to conserve energy while ensuring the zone doesn’t fall too far out of the desired range.

4. Optimize Ventilation and Airflow

• Keep vents clear: Ensure furniture or curtains do not block air supply and return vents.

• Regularly clean filters: Dirty filters restrict airflow, making your system work harder. Replace or clean filters every 1–3 months, depending on usage.

• Inspect the ductwork: Leaks in ducts can lead to significant energy loss. Seal any gaps with professional-grade duct tape or mastic sealant.

5. Use Thermostat Features Wisely

Vine thermostats have smart features to enhance efficiency:

• Enable geofencing: This adjusts settings automatically based on whether you’re home or away.

• Monitor energy usage: Use the app to track heating and cooling patterns and make adjustments to schedules or setpoints.

• Utilize adaptive recovery: If your Vine thermostats support it, this feature gradually adjusts the temperature to ensure comfort by the time you’ve scheduled it, avoiding unnecessary overuse of the HVAC system.

6. Stay Ahead with Maintenance

• Inspect the economizer regularly: Dust, debris, or malfunctioning components can affect free-cooling performance. Clean and maintain the dampers, sensors, and outdoor air intake.

• Schedule professional checkups: A technician can ensure your entire system, including the SmartZone controller and economizer, is functioning efficiently.

Conclusion

Your SmartZone HVAC system, paired with Vine thermostats and EcoJay’s SmartZone PLUS Outdoor Temperature Controller, offers great potential for comfort and efficiency. By implementing smart schedules, leveraging free-cooling, balancing zones, and maintaining your system, you can enjoy a more energy-efficient and comfortable home.

Regular monitoring and adjustments ensure that your HVAC system meets your household's needs while keeping energy costs low.

Sale

SmartZone-4X

Sale Price: $239.99 Original Price: $299.00

WiFi Thermosat -ST300

$99.99

Sale

Outdoor Air Thermostat

Sale Price: $59.99 Original Price: $79.99

Why SmartZone is the best zone controller.

View fullsize

BUY SmartZone Now

• Screwless wiring (push-in) – No screwdriver required
• Color coded leds show inputs and outputs on every terminal – no voltmeter required
• EASY pushbutton & dip switch setup makes configuration a snap and confirmation of settings in just a glance – NO manual needed
• Temperature sensor included & supply temp displayed on the bright led display, visible even in the dark – NO flashlight needed
• MODES SHOWN ON DISPLAY tell you what the board is doing at all times in plain english – NO guessing what codes mean
• SmartZone can be used with any equipment – Heat Pump, Gas, Electric, radiant, geothermal, etc. as long as it is controlled by 24v.
• Single-stage & Multi-Stage equipment can be used (3 heat & 2 cooling stages)
• Heat pump equipment can be used with auxiliary & emergency heat – both electric and dual fuel -  flawlessly with SmartZone (requires heat pump thermostat connected to Zone 1)
• SmartZone can be paired with any thermostat from the most expensive WiFi stat to the cheapest mechanical thermostat.
• Any 24v damper (Spring or power) can be controlled by SmartZone
• Smartzone has exclusive advanced features:
  •     - Economy Mode allows setback of all zones with the     flip of a switch.  When in eco mode, the system will only     energize if zone 1 makes a call.  This feature is great for vacations or if some of the zones are rarely used.
  •     - Fresh air control allows control of an outside air damper and the system fan on a schedule to bring in fresh air in a prescribed amount.  If fresh air control is required, smartzone-4x has it covered with no additional controls required.  Save $
  • - Smartlink: expand to 20 zones by simply connecting multiple 4X boards together with the smartlink bus. Easiest & most cost effective system for more than 5 zones!
• Smart staging & limit protection – by using a sophisticated time and temperature algorithm perfected over decades of programming, smartzone stages up and down in the most effective and efficient manner possible.
• 2nd stage lockout – by setting this dip switch, smartzone will only allow 2nd stage if more than one zone is calling
• Stage from zone 1 thermostat – allows for a multi-stage thermostat to be connected to zone 1 and control zoning instead of SmartZone (not recommended in typical circumstances)